This is the story of the great
war between good and evil. Well, kind of. It starts in a much smaller
package, a simple metaphor that 7th
graders always bought into when we read Rudyard Kipling’s “Rikki-Tikki-Tavi”
(1894), even if they did so unknowingly.
(taken from http://www.mysteryplayground.net/2013/12/rikki-tiki-tavi.html) |
I was first introduced to this
story many years ago as an elementary school student—perhaps third or fourth
grade when I devoured Kipling's The Jungle Book
(not Disney) and Just So Stories.
Soon after discovering the story of the mongoose, I was lounging about trying
to avoid the Las Vegas heat on a Saturday afternoon, when to my surprise, Chuck Jones’s animated version of the story,(narrated by Orson Welles) came on. My
Looney Tunes and Grinch addictions had already established my Chuck Jones
obsession. Like a bird transfixed by Nag, I was glued to the TV.
Fast forward 30 years and my
students were equally hooked by this story of deadly snakes and little Rikki.
Most students admit they like it, even if they pretend not to pay attention.
One of the last years I had 7th graders, I asked one class—the
majority of them reluctant readers—why they liked this story so much.
Predictably, many of them said that they liked snakes or the fighting. One
girl, Cecilie, shyly spoke up and said she thought the story was an embodiment
of good versus evil.
Wow! Where did that come from?
As I’ve thought about that
particular conversation, and discussed similar themes with my (new) science
fiction and fantasy literature class this semester, I know she’s right. This
theme of good triumphing over evil is a universal draw for kids of all ages,
even if they parade as adults; it’s a story so old it’s the essence of our
existence. Well, at least some people think so.
(lifted from http://www.fanpop.com/clubs/the-emperors-new -groove/picks/results/554659/whos-sholder-angel-devil-like-better) |
Regardless, it really makes for
great classroom, boardroom, or break room discussion. My personal favorite literary
battle of good over evil is Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings because of its simple complexities: small and simple and good
upsets the suffocating reaches of evil. However, I think that a mongoose
fighting to defend “his people” from the pure evil nature of these cobras Nag
and Nagaina and the brown snake Karait is the same basic story on a simpler
scale. And when it comes to external conflicts, it’s one that just about
everyone can get behind. Whether you are talking about dark lords, whaling,
video games, cowboys, or playground bullies, everyone roots for the “good guy,”
right? It’s only natural.
P.S. Watching snakes is pretty cool, even if they give
you the heebie jeebies. On a 7th grade field trip to the London Zoo,
my friends and I witnessed two king cobras attacking and then dining on a
handful of white rats. When it’s evil vs. evil, nobody involved wins…except possibly
some 7th grade boys snickering behind protective glass.
I always enjoyed Rikki-Tikki-Tavi as well.
ReplyDeleteMy personal good vs. evil story would have to be The Stand by Stephen King.
I think the theme of good vs evil is the draw for most of us. We tend to prefer stories the "end well". That's what makes book series like "Lord of the Rings", "Percy Jackson", "Harry Potter" and movies like "Star Wars" so popular...as well as almost all Disney movies, regardless of the outcome of the original stories upon which they are often times loosely based ;-)!!
ReplyDelete